Who answers at 2am, who approves a lockout, and what happens to your logs when you leave. Ask these before you compare prices, because the price only makes sense once you know the answers.
Most MDR proposals look the same on the page: 24/7 monitoring, expert analysts, fast response. The difference shows up at night, in the small print and in the report you get afterwards. These questions bring that out early.
Ten questions
Bring these to the first call. A good provider will answer them without having to check.
- Who picks up at 2 a.m., and what can they do on the spot?
- Who approves a lockout on your side?
- How long do you keep our logs, and can we have them back?
- What does a monthly report look like?
- Can we see a redacted incident report?
- What is the median time to contain, and how is it measured?
- Which of our existing tools do you connect to, and what do you ask us to replace?
- Who tunes the alerts, and can we read the tuning log?
- What happens if we move up or down a plan?
- What do we get on the day we leave?
If a vendor cannot show you a report, ask what you are buying.
The answers that matter most
Question five does the most work. A redacted report shows you the timeline, the findings and the language you would be reading at a bad moment. If it runs to 90 pages, or nobody will share one, you have your answer.
Question six needs care. “Time to respond” can mean the time until a ticket opened. Ask for the time from first alert to contained, and ask what contained means in their reports.
Before you sign
Read the contract for the things that did not come up on the sales call.
- Named containment steps your provider may take without calling you.
- Any charge for incident work beyond the monthly fee.
- The date your data leaves, and the format it leaves in.
Then compare prices. You will find you are comparing fewer things, and that the cheapest proposal may leave out the part you wanted most.




