Report WL-2214   Web and API

A password reset link that worked for anyone who asked.

§1 Report sheetWL-2214 / Sample report

Penetration tester at a laptop, a small network device cabled in beside him
Sample engagement WL-2214
1

reset link could take over any customer account

Report sheet

Client

Regional insurer

Test type

Web and API

Scope

Customer portal, eight days.

Findings

1 Critical, 2 High, 6 Low

Result

Account takeover

Tied to the session, not the account.

Written for the client's board. The client is fictional and the name is withheld.

§2.1   The test

We tested the customer portal by hand for eight days, using test accounts the insurer set up for us.

§2.2   How it worked

The reset token was tied to the session of whoever requested it, and not to the account. Any customer account could be taken over.

§2.3   What changed

Tokens are now single use and bound to the account. The retest confirmed it.

§3 TimelineWL-2214 / Sample report

Thirty-eight days, step by step.

Sample timeline, taken from the test log. Every action has a time.

When

Step

By

Day 0

Scope, test windows and stop contact signed

Lead

Day 1

Test accounts set up, sign-in and reset flows mapped

Tester

Day 3

Reset token tied to the wrong session

Tester

Day 3

Second test account taken over, proof saved

Tester

Day 3

Named contact phoned with the proof and a fix

Tester

Day 8

Remaining flows tested, testing ends

Tester

After the test

Day 8

Report read through with the client on a call

Lead

Day 12

Tokens made single use and bound to the account

Client IT

Day 38

Retest: old links refused

Tester

§4 FindingsWL-2214 / Sample report

Nine findings. Three shown in full.

Severity

Finding

Closed

Critical

Reset token not bound to the account

Day 38

High

Reset tokens could be used twice

Day 38

High

No notice to the customer after a reset

Day 38

The other 6 stay in the client's copy.

Tester at a dark desk reading an attack path on a laptop
Findings, sample client
1 Critical  Â·  2 High  Â·  6 Low

§5 Client noteWL-2214 / Sample report

We read that reset code a dozen times in review. It took someone actually trying it to see the problem.

Development manager, regional insurer (fictional client)
What changed

Tokens work once, for one account

Customers are told after every reset

Reset flows tested at each release

§6 More reportsEnd of WL-2214