How to read a severity score without arguing about it

Tester holding a card cloning device beside the access reader on a server room door

A CVSS number is a starting point. It describes the flaw, and it knows nothing about your business. Every finding in our reports carries the score and a plain sentence beside it.

Most arguments about severity are really arguments about what the flaw leads to. So we write that part down.

Three questions for each finding

  • What can someone do with this today?
  • What did we need before we could use it?
  • What would it cost you if we were not the ones doing it?

If a finding needs a meeting to explain, the report did not do its job.

Agree the order, not the number

You do not need everyone to agree a finding is exactly 8.1. You need them to agree what gets fixed first, and that is the conversation the read-through call is for.

About the author

Ines founded Wardline and still reads every scope before it leaves the building. Fictional author, demo content.

Related field notes