Free survey, Mon–Sat 7–20+1-555-0178No-heat line, every night24/7 · under 4 hServing the North ShoreBrightwater, MN

Oil, Propane or Heat Pump: What a Winter Really Costs

Same house, same thermostat, six ways to heat it. The table we print on every survey report.
Round smart thermostat on a plaster wall

Heating bills are hard to compare because every fuel is sold in a different unit. So we turn them all into the same thing: the cost of one kilowatt-hour of heat delivered into the house.

The typical house

A 1,900 sq ft Brightwater home needs about 16,500 kWh of heat a year. With 2025–26 fuel and power prices, here is what that costs:

  • Electric baseboard: $0.21 per kWh of heat · $3,470 a year
  • Heating-oil boiler: $0.19 · $3,140
  • Propane furnace: $0.17 · $2,810
  • Natural-gas furnace: $0.09 · $1,490
  • Cold-climate heat pump: $0.07 · $1,160
  • Heat pump + 8 kW solar: $0.03 · $460

The assumptions

Seasonal efficiency: oil 85%, propane 92%, gas 95%, heat pump 3.2. The solar share is the part of winter heating covered by the roof over a full year of net metering.

Your survey report fills in your own prices. Gas homes see the smallest gap — and we say so.

Written By

Customer Care & Grants Lead
Customer care and grants lead at Hearthwell. She files the rebates, answers the no-heat line on cold nights and writes most of the winter notes.
All articles by Megan Ferris
Keep reading

More on staying warm for less.

All Articles
Free heat-loss survey

Switch before the first hard frost.

A 45-minute visit, a room-by-room heat-loss report and a fixed price within 48 hours.

Book My Survey
Rather talk?

Talk to a surveyor, not a call centre.

+1-555-0178 · Mon–Sat 7–20[email protected]