On-Site Solar or a PPA? A One-Page Decision Tree for CFOs

Roof space, credit, lease length and appetite for capex decide most of it. Compare both on one page, in your own cash flow.
Solar carport canopies over an office car park with electric cars charging

We are vendor-neutral, so we get asked this question a lot. The honest answer is that four facts about your business decide most of it, and you can answer them in a meeting.

The four questions

  • How much usable roof or car park do you control, and for how long?
  • Would you rather spend capital or sign a long contract?
  • How strong is your credit rating for a 10–20 year agreement?
  • Do you need the renewable claim on site, or is a contract for supply enough?

When on-site wins

Long leases, good roofs and spare capital usually favour owning on-site solar. The savings start the day it switches on and the asset stays on your balance sheet.

When a PPA wins

Short leases, little roof and a preference for operating cost point to an off-site power purchase agreement. You fix a price for 10–15 years and buy the output of a project elsewhere.

What we put on the page

We model both options side by side in your own cash flow: year-one cost, ten-year total, risk to price and volume, and what each does to your Scope 2 number. Ines Varga’s team has negotiated forty PPAs and will tell you when neither option is worth it.

Written By

Head of Net-Zero Strategy
Head of Net-Zero Strategy at Kestrel. Margot spent nine years planning grids for a utility before joining in 2017; she turns audit findings into roadmaps a board can fund and writes the Kestrel Brief every month.
All briefings by Margot Ellery
Keep reading

Three more briefings for the budget meeting.

All Insights